Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread Display Modes
Old 03-17-2015, 03:12   #1
USER1_74
Registered User
 
USER1_74's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 2,699
USER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond repute
question about damage : 2 SDG VS stigma

regarding damage formula I've a question :

2 x SDG's and bonus of stigma work in the same way? (the question is for active skill not melee)

for easy example consider a +12 385 BP king pure warrior: If He hit with charging vortex some1 with full sdg (14) and after remove shield (2 sdg) and some 1 stig him He do the same damage on the same opponent????
if not pls explain
ty
__________________
Greedy
Water-Thunderstriker-Ninja (52k max attack)
478 BP
Full +12-7P7 P12 anima
NewChallenge EU server
USER1_74 is offline   Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Old 03-17-2015, 04:21   #2
XShinryuX
Survivor
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Malaysia
Posts: 2,396
XShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond reputeXShinryuX has a reputation beyond repute
By default logic, yes because CV is a skill.
However, if he melee people normally, it will be no, because he would have lost the SDG bonus.
XShinryuX is offline   Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Old 03-17-2015, 04:45   #3
ghfdhhdf
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Posts: 4,272
ghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond reputeghfdhhdf has a reputation beyond repute
No, you will do more damage with stig and 2 less sdg than with 2 more sdg and no stig. The attack bonus from stig stacks with the bonus from sdg, but the sdgs are just added together, so stig is more effective.

For example, with 100 attack and 4 sdg, adding 2 more gives you 100*1.9 = 190. Adding stig on the other hand gives you 100*1.6*1.3=208

Last edited by ghfdhhdf; 03-17-2015 at 04:48.
ghfdhhdf is offline   Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Old 03-17-2015, 05:45   #4
USER1_74
Registered User
 
USER1_74's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 2,699
USER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond repute
ty vm Rachel

Quote:
Originally Posted by ghfdhhdf View Post
No, you will do more damage with stig and 2 less sdg than with 2 more sdg and no stig. The attack bonus from stig stacks with the bonus from sdg, but the sdgs are just added together, so stig is more effective.

For example, with 100 attack and 4 sdg, adding 2 more gives you 100*1.9 = 190. Adding stig on the other hand gives you 100*1.6*1.3=208
ty
that it explain many things
my main was archer (176 str) with +12p7 spear in alternate and stigged speedgun had very high damage!
now as pure warrior the damage seem little lower :-(
__________________
Greedy
Water-Thunderstriker-Ninja (52k max attack)
478 BP
Full +12-7P7 P12 anima
NewChallenge EU server

Last edited by USER1_74; 03-17-2015 at 05:49.
USER1_74 is offline   Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Old 03-17-2015, 09:07   #5
sundancerx
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,672
sundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond reputesundancerx has a reputation beyond repute
Quote:
Originally Posted by USER1_74 View Post
regarding damage formula I've a question :

2 x SDG's and bonus of stigma work in the same way? (the question is for active skill not melee)

for easy example consider a +12 385 BP king pure warrior: If He hit with charging vortex some1 with full sdg (14) and after remove shield (2 sdg) and some 1 stig him He do the same damage on the same opponent????
if not pls explain
ty
some realistic example:
35k attack
vs.
20k defense
57pct bless

charging vortex:
[35k x (1 + 2.10) -20k ] [0.90] [1-0.57] = 34.3k (with stig =46.8k)

[[35k x (1 + 1.80) (1.30)] - 20k] [0.90] [1-0.57]= 41.6k

you can weigh the pros/cons of pure warrior vs. warrior with stig. imo, pure is still better especially in situations where someone can stig the warrior.
__________________
Originally Posted by awakening
tranny can be awesome, but I can't say the same for your level of intelligent.
sundancerx is offline   Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Old 03-18-2015, 00:12   #6
USER1_74
Registered User
 
USER1_74's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 2,699
USER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond reputeUSER1_74 has a reputation beyond repute
ty vm

Quote:
Originally Posted by sundancerx View Post
some realistic example:
35k attack
vs.
20k defense
57pct bless

charging vortex:
[35k x (1 + 2.10) -20k ] [0.90] [1-0.57] = 34.3k (with stig =46.8k)

[[35k x (1 + 1.80) (1.30)] - 20k] [0.90] [1-0.57]= 41.6k

you can weigh the pros/cons of pure warrior vs. Warrior with stig. Imo, pure is still better especially in situations where someone can stig the warrior.
+1
__________________
Greedy
Water-Thunderstriker-Ninja (52k max attack)
478 BP
Full +12-7P7 P12 anima
NewChallenge EU server
USER1_74 is offline   Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:10.